Guide

Soft 404 Errors: What They Mean and How to Fix Them

A soft 404 is a page Google treats as not found even though your server says everything is fine. Fix them and Google stops wasting crawls on pages that cannot rank.

A soft 404 is a page that tells visitors it is missing, or has almost nothing on it, while the server still returns a normal 200 OK status. Google decides the page is effectively not found and leaves it out of the index. The fix is to return the correct status code, restore real content, or redirect to a close match.

What a soft 404 actually is

A normal 404 is honest. The server says the page does not exist, and Google drops it. A soft 404 is a mismatch. The browser shows "page not found" or an empty page, but the server reported success.

Google flags these in Search Console under Pages, in the list of reasons pages are not indexed, as Soft 404. Our guide on fixing 404 errors at scale covers true 404s. This guide covers the confusing cousin.

Common causes

Causes

Why pages get flagged as soft 404

Error page returns 200

A custom not found page that sends a 200 status instead of 404 or 410.

Thin or empty pages

Category, tag or search pages with no products or posts on them.

Redirects to the homepage

Deleted pages sent to the home page or another unrelated page.

Out of stock pages

Product pages with no product, no price and no alternatives.

Broken templates

A template that loads but fails to pull in the page content.

Blocked resources

Scripts or content blocked from Google, so the page renders empty.

How to find soft 404s

  1. Open Search Console and go to Pages. Look for Soft 404 under the reasons pages are not indexed.
  2. Click the reason to see the list of affected URLs.
  3. Test a sample with URL Inspection. Check the live test, the rendered screenshot and the HTTP response.
  4. Check your own server. Request a made up URL and see what status code comes back. If it is 200, your error page is the culprit for many of them.

Step by step fix

1. Sort the URLs by type

Group them: removed pages, empty listings, out of stock products, and pages that should have content but render blank. Each group has a different fix.

2. Removed pages: return the right status

If a page is gone for good, send a real 404 or 410. If a close replacement exists, use a 301 redirect to it. Do not redirect to the homepage by default.

3. Empty listings: add content or remove them

A category with nothing in it has no reason to be indexed. Either fill it, merge it into a related page, or return a 404 or noindex it. Check our guide to noindex and robots.txt mistakes before using noindex widely.

4. Out of stock products: keep what helps

If the product is coming back, keep the page with a clear status and related items. If it is gone for good, redirect to the nearest equivalent or remove it.

5. Blank pages that should have content

This is a rendering or template fault. Compare what URL Inspection shows with what a visitor sees. If Google sees a blank page, find out why. Our guide to JavaScript SEO rendering covers one common reason.

6. Validate the fix

After the fix, use Validate Fix in the Soft 404 report so Search Console re-checks the URLs.

How soft 404s differ from other index statuses

StatusWhat Google seesUsual fix
404 or 410Server says the page is goneRedirect if a match exists, otherwise leave it
Soft 404Server says OK, page looks empty or missingCorrect status code, real content or a close redirect
Crawled, currently not indexedPage fetched but not judged worth indexingImprove the page quality and links
How soft 404s compare with similar statuses in Search Console.

If a page you care about shows crawled but not indexed instead, see our guide to crawled, currently not indexed. For the wider question, our short answer on whether 404 errors hurt SEO explains how Google treats them.

When to call for help

Get help when soft 404s run into the thousands, when the pages are ones that used to earn traffic, or when the cause is a template or rendering fault you cannot trace. These are signs of a wider crawl problem, not a one page error.

We start with the crawl evidence and the Search Console data, then fix the cause. See our technical SEO fixes work, or ask for a free SEO triage.

FAQ

Questions owners ask us

Is a soft 404 worse than a normal 404?

Not worse for your site as a whole, but harder to spot. A true 404 is clear to Google and is dropped from the index. A soft 404 sends mixed signals, and a page you wanted indexed may be excluded without any obvious error on your side.

Should I redirect every soft 404 to the homepage?

No. Google can treat redirects to unrelated pages, such as the homepage, as soft 404s as well. Redirect to a close equivalent page. If none exists, return a real 404 or 410 status.

How long until a fixed soft 404 clears in Search Console?

Google has to recrawl the page first, and nobody can promise when. Use URL Inspection to request indexing on key pages, then use Validate Fix in the report so Search Console can track the change.

Get started

Tell us where it hurts.

Your site, what changed and when. We reply with a first read on the cause.